Friday, June 29, 2012
Capital Markets Update
By Louis S. Barnes Friday, June 29th, 2012
Reading media reports of economics is usually an exercise in decoding political bias and trying to find the center of things. Today we’re in enough trouble that to understand “news” we must also strip away hope and pessimism.
Big week for all of that.
First thing first: the US has lost some forward momentum, but is not entering recession. Consumer spending did not rise at all in May, dead flat, but orders for new durable goods doubled the forecast. New claims for unemployment insurance are running 385,000 weekly, up 15% from last year’s best run since 2008, but not spiking. There are some flickers from housing, but that’s all (more below). Definitive reports for June come next Monday and Friday, purchasing managers and payrolls.
Europe… we have another “relief rally” underway today (Dow up 220, gold up $55), as yet another Brussels summit has delivered yet more fibs to buy time. However, this time is different. After all prior can-kicking, markets took the bait, believing that Europe intended actual material progress. This time a lot of people (including me) had talked themselves into believing the euro zone was about to pull its own plug, maybe as soon as this weekend. Today’s relief rally does not reflect any belief whatever in European progress; it is instead a cynical, tired, shoulder-slump at the sight of people without the courage to take the Luger to a quiet spot and do the honorable thing.
The tell-tale as always in these last years: the 10-year T-note. The sum-total extent of relief is a rise in yield from 1.57% to 1.65%. Mortgages high-threes, unchanged.
Housing is improving, but in a 17-step program to recovery has reached perhaps stage two. Case-Shiller found a 0.7% rise in prices in April to a level about even with one year ago. The FHFA House Price Index (which I much prefer) found a 3.0% price increase year-over year, essentially all of it in the first four months of 2012, the most recent data from April (housing data suffer terrible lag, especially the accurate stuff).
Today’s greatest mystery: where is the distressed inventory? www.lpsvcs.com has the best data: the number of homes in foreclosure somewhere has not changed in a year. Serious delinquency (90-days late or in foreclosure) has fallen from 7.86% of all homes to 7.37%, a huge swamp draining imperceptibly. Total foreclosure sales were only 66,000 in April versus 4.5 million shadow inventory in terminal distress, outflow not significantly larger than inflow.
For descriptive amusement, visit www.fhfa.gov and scroll to pages 36 and 37 of the HPI, the 20-Best and 20-Worst markets of 303 total MSAs. My home town, very-low-inventory Boulder, CO ranks as the 10th best of all, and we feel like it, although our one-year price gain is only 2.35%, and 5-year plus 1.60%. Bend, OR ranks third-best with 4.85% appreciation last year; however, its overall 5-year result has been minus-43%. The 20-Worst: #4 Las Vegas has lost 60% of value in five years, including 8.79% last year. #16 Atlanta: minus 23% 5-year overall, including 6.33% lost last year.
We have a long way to go before housing will lead the economy up.
Speaking of leading… the economic stories this week and year are dwarfed by events in leadership often responsible for the economic results. The principal reason that housing is unable to lead the economy: there is no public policy. Congress is entertained by gridlock on the subject, the Right hating any federal assistance whatever, and the Left amused by hating all bankers. Mr. Bernanke, the leadership hero of this time, in January orchestrated the finest housing-policy recommendations of the decade and got no response from any other office of government.
Competing theories of leadership: great people appear and then move events; alternately, deeply troubled times call great people forward. Look around the world, and it’s hard to figure by either theory how the supply could be so thin.
Then from nowhere, a man granted high station and for seven years in office amounting to nothing, from that nowhere somehow found greatness. Thank you, John Roberts. Not for saving ObamaCare, but for showing the way beyond partisanship.
Friday, June 22, 2012
Capital Markets Update
By Louis S. Barnes Friday, June 22nd, 2012
Markets show justifiable concern at a steady flow of soft data all over the world, but it’s hard to figure disappointment that the Fed did nothing dramatic this week.
The Fed’s QE operations have been designed to pull down long-term interest rates, to prevent runs on banks, and to ease credit. In the last 80 days the run from Europe has accomplished Jobs One and Two, cutting 10-year T-note yields by one-third, and all but drowned the US system in cash. The general shortage of credit is a different matter, a regulatory failure to which the Fed has formally objected repeatedly, yet compounded by its contribution to the national mania to over-regulate.
Broad policy here is in European-quality disarray, the stimulus-austerity conundrum just as unresolved as there. Economic conditions here are far better, banks immeasurably healthier, our whole situation improved by our wise decision to form a national government before issuing national currency.
If we’re in stimulus-austerity gridlock, what to do? What resource to draw upon? I have an idea, but you’ll have to wait through a parable and a true story.
An unemployed economist at last gave up on finding a new position, swallowed his pride and took a construction job. His first-day task: to carry a pile of bricks down from the roof of a new 2-story building. After humping the first load, invention came to mind.
He tied one end of a long rope to a tree, pulled the other end to the roof-top, threaded it through a pulley on a beam at roof-edge, tied it to a barrel found there, and filled the barrel with bricks. Pleased with his plan to lower the bricks instead of carrying, he fairly danced down the stairs to the anchor tree.
In retrospect, he felt that his sole mistake was to hang on to the rope as he untied it from the tree. The loaded barrel, three or four times the weight of the economist, as it descended lifted him rapidly toward roof-top, and bashed him as they passed each other. Just as the man’s fingers crushed into the pulley, the barrel struck ground, bricks breaking through the bottom, and the physics of the affair reversed, barrel whacking economist on its way back up and his transit down.
Onlookers felt the economist did make one further error. After landing on the pile of bricks… he let go of the rope.
Just a story. Another begins with the Great Society formation of Medicare and then Medicaid. Initial costs were trivial: in 1970 Federal health programs were 0.7% of GDP. Today, about 4% of GDP, $769 billion last year. But in the ’80s as costs spiraled, Congress moved more and more of the burden to the states via “un-funded mandate”: Thou Shalt Spend, But Thou Shall Find Thine Own Revenue. Cumulative state health spending now runs another $400 billion, still growing at triple CPI.
ObamaCare put all of its chips on coverage, nothing but argle-bargle to address cost. US healthcare spending, public and private combined, is about 18% of GDP, only about half supported by tax revenue. Our peer nations spend about 10% of GDP and get the same results that we do (see T.R. Reid’s “The Healing of America”). If we could cut costs by 6% of GDP, that would cut the overall Federal deficit by 80%.
Unanticipated physics… Here in Colorado, health spending is now 33% of the budget; 40% goes to K-12, 14% to public safety, and higher education has been chopped to 8% (headed to zero). The higher-ed cuts have been displaced to tuition increases running quadruple CPI (the Corleones should have had it so good), in turn displaced to student loan debt, the only category of credit growing, actually exploding as in good ol’ subprime days, a burden on youth without precedent.
The second half of Mr. Obama’s unfortunate “The private sector is fine” paragraph lamented job cuts by state and local government. Skinflints are not at fault: runaway health care is the problem. Whether the Supreme Court cans ObamaCare doesn’t matter. It will fail of its own weight.
Back to the austerity-stimulus conundrum, and one public resource sitting in plain sight, untapped: if we would use our silly damned heads we might get somewhere.
Friday, June 15, 2012
Capital Markets Update
By Louis S. Barnes Friday, June 15th, 2012
Now we wait. At 2:30 ET Sunday come Greek election results and who-knows-what explosion at the opening of Asian markets Sunday night. More likely: a few more frozen days to digest the results, and any number of empty cans kicked into nearby walls.
The biggest event next week will be the Wednesday conclusion of the Fed's meeting. The stock market this week began to trade up on bad news (a small rise in unemployment claims, a dinky drop in industrial production) on the assumption that bad news would mean QE3 from the Fed, which must be good news for stocks no matter how ugly the reality might be.
Last week I compared this market-think to trained seals, and today I apologize to seals everywhere. Pick a more appropriate critter. If you took Psych I, you discovered that you could get a lab rat to sell its soul for a dozen Rice Krispies. Rats conditioned to central bank action are found not just in neckties at the NYSE, but all over the globe.
Since WW II, the immense economic strength of the US combined with reslove at all central banks to avoid a Depression replay has enabled rescue from all severe financial crises. All rats and non-rats assume that rescue is just a flip of switch. An unpleasant crew on the Right and righteous Libertarians think that rescue corrupts the morals of rats, but given the raw material, why worry? Rescue when we can is right and proper.
Europe's situation today is different from all other financial crises in the last 70 years. Some day a crisis was bound to come along that could not be rescued, and this one has a crucial marker: tectonic strain has built ever since the misbegotten euro rolled out, and efforts to meliorate have resulted only in more strain.
What will the ultimate breach look like, and what is the hazard here?
I may be the only optimist alive!
There is a small chance that Europe, looking over the precipice will decide that the whole can adopt German behavior, and that Germans can become Californians. However, that adaptation would take many, many years, and might well inflict greater drag and hazard on the world than an all-at-once reset.
The vastly more likely fault-line lurch would take place in one of two general ways. The orderly way: one Friday afternoon after US markets close, announce a euro-wide bank holiday, then a skip-Monday re-open in local currencies. The disorderly: stay in denial until markets pull the plug, and then a holiday.
Chaos and losses follow, especially to anyone who expected repayment in euros by non-Ger/Neth/Aus/Fin entities. However, healing would begin instantly. Local currencies would trade wildly for a few weeks, but find levels; all local central banks still exist; all senior business management knows local-currency trade and hedging; and all local political structures can again make local decisions.
As most of Europe will devalue, exporters to Europe will either have to devalue or to sell less and slow. China would feel the worst bind: devalue versus the dollar to stay with Europe, and risk US trade war? Or keep the dollar-peg, slow, and begin to reform?
Japan might be the worst exposed, but its vulnerabilities are local: its banks and citizens own 95% of government debt, and its ultimate default will be internal.
Emerging nations -- Brazil-Russia-India -- would feel the breakdown in the unsustainable global-trade conveyor. However, the good-news effect: pretense exposed, rationalize their economies to reality as best they can.
Here. Here? Falling commodity prices remove any threat of inflation, and free the Fed to take any measures necessary. Our banks are not at run-risk: they are drowning in stable deposits. We are less reliant on exports than any large nation. Our housing market is turning, applications for purchase loans up 13% last week. New data are on the flat side, but the economy is more uncertain than foreshadowing rollover.
A euro-breakup would mark the end of a painful and irrational time, and resolution to the paired plagues of the last twenty years: unsustainable sovereign debt funding unsustainable trade. Long past due, inevitable, and a good, good thing.
Now we wait. At 2:30 ET Sunday come Greek election results and who-knows-what explosion at the opening of Asian markets Sunday night. More likely: a few more frozen days to digest the results, and any number of empty cans kicked into nearby walls.
The biggest event next week will be the Wednesday conclusion of the Fed's meeting. The stock market this week began to trade up on bad news (a small rise in unemployment claims, a dinky drop in industrial production) on the assumption that bad news would mean QE3 from the Fed, which must be good news for stocks no matter how ugly the reality might be.
Last week I compared this market-think to trained seals, and today I apologize to seals everywhere. Pick a more appropriate critter. If you took Psych I, you discovered that you could get a lab rat to sell its soul for a dozen Rice Krispies. Rats conditioned to central bank action are found not just in neckties at the NYSE, but all over the globe.
Since WW II, the immense economic strength of the US combined with reslove at all central banks to avoid a Depression replay has enabled rescue from all severe financial crises. All rats and non-rats assume that rescue is just a flip of switch. An unpleasant crew on the Right and righteous Libertarians think that rescue corrupts the morals of rats, but given the raw material, why worry? Rescue when we can is right and proper.
Europe's situation today is different from all other financial crises in the last 70 years. Some day a crisis was bound to come along that could not be rescued, and this one has a crucial marker: tectonic strain has built ever since the misbegotten euro rolled out, and efforts to meliorate have resulted only in more strain.
What will the ultimate breach look like, and what is the hazard here?
I may be the only optimist alive!
There is a small chance that Europe, looking over the precipice will decide that the whole can adopt German behavior, and that Germans can become Californians. However, that adaptation would take many, many years, and might well inflict greater drag and hazard on the world than an all-at-once reset.
The vastly more likely fault-line lurch would take place in one of two general ways. The orderly way: one Friday afternoon after US markets close, announce a euro-wide bank holiday, then a skip-Monday re-open in local currencies. The disorderly: stay in denial until markets pull the plug, and then a holiday.
Chaos and losses follow, especially to anyone who expected repayment in euros by non-Ger/Neth/Aus/Fin entities. However, healing would begin instantly. Local currencies would trade wildly for a few weeks, but find levels; all local central banks still exist; all senior business management knows local-currency trade and hedging; and all local political structures can again make local decisions.
As most of Europe will devalue, exporters to Europe will either have to devalue or to sell less and slow. China would feel the worst bind: devalue versus the dollar to stay with Europe, and risk US trade war? Or keep the dollar-peg, slow, and begin to reform?
Japan might be the worst exposed, but its vulnerabilities are local: its banks and citizens own 95% of government debt, and its ultimate default will be internal.
Emerging nations -- Brazil-Russia-India -- would feel the breakdown in the unsustainable global-trade conveyor. However, the good-news effect: pretense exposed, rationalize their economies to reality as best they can.
Here. Here? Falling commodity prices remove any threat of inflation, and free the Fed to take any measures necessary. Our banks are not at run-risk: they are drowning in stable deposits. We are less reliant on exports than any large nation. Our housing market is turning, applications for purchase loans up 13% last week. New data are on the flat side, but the economy is more uncertain than foreshadowing rollover.
A euro-breakup would mark the end of a painful and irrational time, and resolution to the paired plagues of the last twenty years: unsustainable sovereign debt funding unsustainable trade. Long past due, inevitable, and a good, good thing.
Friday, June 8, 2012
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



