Home Scouting Report

Friday, March 13, 2015

A Little Recovery


Capital Markets Update

By Louis S. Barnes                                    Friday, March 13, 2015

Long-term rates came down a hair this week from the prior three-week spike, but there is no sign of another flirtation with the February lows. The third-straight monthly slide in retail sales and oil to $45/bbl might have taken the edge off of Fed-fear, but did not. Lowest-fee mortgages are 4.00%-ish, the 10-year T-note well above 2.00%.

Everyone assumes the Fed next Wednesday will remove “patience” from its post-meeting language, opening the door to its first rate hike since 2006. Many in markets think it’s coming in June, fewer think September. But it’s coming.

The Fed’s purpose is to protect us from extremes in the business cycle. Capitalist economies tend to self-reinforcing spirals up or down with violently bad endings.

When the Fed sits down to talk about action, the entire internal conversation is based on the mathematics of the business cycle — equations, charts, and models. All of necessity backward looking, vulnerable to truly changed conditions. Each cycle from 1945 to 2000 was carbon-copy — each expansion, tightening, recession, easing, and recovery. A perfect world for models.

But, beginning in 2001, a jobless recovery, a burst stock bubble, a false recovery based on undiscovered (incredibly) credit and housing bubbles, six years at 0% cost of money, and today’s uneven and iffy recovery — nothing in the last 15 years resembled back-look models. Add to that uncertainty: the Fed and markets assume that changes in monetary policy take most of two years to take full effect.

The Fed’s mathism and models are honestly the best it can do, but also provide a mask beneficial to the Fed. Better that complexity conceals from civilians the reality: its decisions are a collective dampened thumb stuck into the breeze.

The mathism and thumbs are directed at two questions: first, what is the capacity of the economy to grow without inflation, expressed as the Non-Accelerating Inflation Rate of Unemployment? NAIRU, pronounced like the jacket. If too many are unemployed, our spiral sinks into deflation and the Fed can and must spew invented cash; too few unemployed, and the Fed must tighten long before wages grow too fast.

The second question: Where do we set the Fed funds rate? Lowering or raising on what slope? Found in every numbing Fed paper today, this notation: r*. Beaten to death in a speech by the new Prez of the Cleveland Fed, Loretta Mester, r* is the “equilibrium Fed funds rate,” the result of this equation:


The unintended(?) black comedy in Mester’s speech: “The big issue is that the equilibrium real rate, r*, is unobserved. Incidentally, so are the level of potential output and the natural rate of unemployment.” Translation: we’re guessing at the values of the variables. In a heating economy we’re going to jack Fed funds somewhere above inflation… but r* looks scientific and precise. Really cool equation.

Back to the business cycle. Two things drive the spiral: unemployment, as above assuming it translates into wage gains, and second the credit cycle, in a hot economy when new loans, the rising value of collateral, and wages all chase each other.

Today we have very little wage growth. John Williams, sensible Prez of the San Francisco Fed in a speech last week says he knows the unemployment capacity limit is 5.25%: tighten now, and gradually higher rates in two years will offset the wage effects of full employment. But, this time looks very different: global competition, IT effects, predatory exports (China, Germany), and a hyper-dollar all push down on wages. Our job growth is in low-wage sectors not subject to competition or IT. Waiting tables.

There is no up-winding in the credit cycle. Mortgage rates returned to 70-year lows without any up-tick in purchase applications. Very good and tough new bank regulation, run-proofing the system and intercepting bad ideas (subprime car loans, “leveraged loans”…) have already tightened credit.

The bond and mortgage markets fear a Fed “normalization” marching upward mindlessly to levels appropriate before 2000, 3.5%-4%. I hope next Wednesday the Fed tamps down that view of normal, and how long it should take to get there.

Friday, March 6, 2015

...And Bears, Oh My!


Capital Markets Update

By Louis S. Barnes                                    Friday, March 6, 2015

Brace thyself.

Mortgage rates are above 4.00% for the first time since December, taken up by an overnight rout in the 10-year T-note (and a lot of other markets). 10s last night were hanging on to chart support at 2.11%, and are now 2.25%.

As always here, take it one piece at a time. First of all, the dive in 10s from 2.35% at Christmas to 1.65% in early February — one-third in six weeks! — was a tad peculiar. Most of us thought the cause was exceedingly low yields overseas, and every major central bank trying to devalue its currency versus the dollar. I still believe that, and believe foreign conditions are a strong counterweight to Fed tightening. The Fed thinks so, too, which may force it to tighten harder, right or wrong.

Charts aside, the overnight driver was an up-side surprise in February payrolls, another 295,000 jobs. Despite claims of a “strong” report and violent market reaction, the thing is shot full of holes. One-third of the jobs were hospitality and retail, protected from foreign competition, but dead-end, unstable, and poor-paying. Average hourly earnings rose $0.03, 0.01% for the month and decelerated to 2.0% year over year. More people at work even at lousy wages means more national income, but at this rate of change, increasing inflation is impossible.

Trading in every market today says they are worried about the Fed, not inflation. Every market has interpreted the February job data as conclusive impetus to fed tightening. Every market has been slow to take the Fed at its word, day after day for many months that it is aching to lift off from 0%. Six years-plus at 0%, every Fed economic forecast wrong on the happy side, disbelief has been good business.

The stock market usually rises on good economic news. This winter it began to counter-trade. Good news means the Fed is comin’, so sell. Midday today, the Dow is off 238 and looks worse.

The currency complex confirms. The ECB next week begins $60 billion per month QE, flooding the world with euros, last-ditch uber-easing. The Fed is about to tighten. Hence the euro just this morning lost 2% of its value, trading at $1.08, the lowest in 13 years. QE helps economies three ways (Wonder Bread helps 12 ways): portfolio effect, pushing investors to take risk, a silly thing to do in Europe; forcing down long-term rates, which in Europe are already down, in Germany below zero beyond 7-year maturities; and weaken your currency. ECB QE will bring only the last, a euro weak enough to help Club Med (absurdly low for Germany).

Currencies are odd stuff. A low euro does not help versus any other country also devaluing, which every competitor has except China, which will soon be forced to, and except the US. The US is in then position of Club Med at the outset of the euro. In part we feel rich: everything we buy from overseas has gotten cheaper. But that’s a hollow and fleeting victory. The wage component of everything produced overseas — goods and services — has fallen in value, pushing down on US wages. Zero-sum is in play:

Friday, February 27, 2015

A Little Better


Capital Markets Update

By Louis S. Barnes                                    Friday, February 27, 2015

Mortgage interest rates improved this past week as economic data was mixed. Economic data stronger than expected included the December Case Shiller 20 City Home Price Index, January New Home Sales, January Core CPI, January Durable Goods Orders, the December FHFA Home Price Index, the second look at Q4 GDP, and the University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Index. Q4 GDP growth was revised down to 2.2% but higher than the 2.1% expected. Economic data weaker than expected included January Existing Home Sales, the February Consumer Confidence Index, weekly jobless claims, January CPI, January Durable Goods Orders excluding transportation orders, the February Chicago Purchasing Managers Index, and January Pending Home Sales. Also of note, the Treasury auctioned $90 billion of 2 Year Notes, 5 Year Notes, and 7 Year Notes, which were met with somewhat soft demand. Fed Chair Yellen testified before the Senate and House and indicated that the Fed would be patient with any rate increase. The Fed would like to be confident that the economic recovery will continue and that inflation will increase over time.

The Dow Jones Industrial Average is currently at 18,189, up slightly on the week. The crude oil spot price is currently at $48.95 per barrel, down over $1 per barrel on the week. The Dollar strengthened versus the Yen and Euro on the week.

Next week look toward Monday’s Personal Income and Outlays and ISM Manufacturing Index, Thursday’s Jobless Claims, and Friday’s February employment report and International Trade report as potential market moving events.

Friday, February 20, 2015