Friday, February 3, 2012
Capital Markets Update
By Louis S. Barnes Friday, February 3rd, 2012
In a double surprise, the job market may at last have begun to revive, but the double-the-forecast, 243,000-job surge in January has done little harm to mortgages. We are still near 4.00%; 10-year T-notes up from 1.82%, but holding nicely at 1.95%.
Ordinarily a payroll jump like this would have killed us, especially in combination with strong results in the two ISM surveys for January: manufacturing to 54.1 from 53.1 in December, and service-sector way up to 56.8 from 52.6 last month. Some of the calm reaction in markets is suspicion — few other data confirm a big economic turn. Europe is a continuing cause of deep anxiety, but quiet this week, nothing but the muffled clanking of picks and shovels in the bottom of its ever-deeper hole.
And housing hangs over everything in the US economy, all measures of prices in continuing decline through December. But, to his great credit, Mr. Obama devoted a speech this week to housing, including new proposals. “This housing crisis struck right at the heart of what it means to be middle class in America: our homes.” Right!
The proposals will be without effect, but that’s not Mr. Obama’s fault. That two years have passed without proposals or priority or even mention, that is his fault, but give him full praise for saying out loud: “Hey, there’s an elephant in this living room!” Why there are no effective proposals, and why it’s beyond even the President’s power to put them forward is a tale of human nature. We know perfectly well what to do, but several things in ourselves and our political process prevent action.
Federal housing finance agencies created in the Great Depression were by far the most effective aspect of the New Deal, perhaps more so than all the rest put together. Aside from restoration of credit, the miracle of government guarantee made mortgage lending easy as apple pie. Guarantee and uniform underwriting standards — sound ones! — made previously illiquid and expensive mortgages as easy to transfer as shares of stock, and cheap, long after the Depression was gone.
For good or ill, as early as the end of WW II our homes became the stores of our national household wealth. Got to put it someplace. Stock market guys would like it to be their market, but it has its own epic instability. Houses it was. The original stop-the-Depression charter of the mortgage agencies became ordinary everyday-everybody utilities. We let them bloat, 1985-2004, for the interest of their stockholders, an inherently unstable situation. Even before mortgage credit went bonkers, ca. 2002, and the push for home ownership ran beyond qualified candidates, the ease of mortgage finance had likely over-fed housing wealth.
Here in the aftermath of the Bubble it is convenient to have someone to blame for our pain. “Fannie and Freddie” have become curse words. Profanities. They were NOT responsible for the $2 trillion in toxic loans, but they are big, fat targets for the Right, hating all government, also oddly the agencies’ boosters on the Left. Hell hath no fury like a social engineer scorned.
The truly culpable parties — Wall Street bankers — have made a clean getaway. John Dillinger and Clyde Barrow would still be in business if they had gone to Princeton, gotten MBAs, and learned to lie properly.
The result is self-inflicted paralysis. The plain-sight truth: for housing to recover we must re-activate Fannie. In a time of falling collateral value, private lenders cannot lend, and we must rely on government guarantee. That’s as certain as the Pope’s religion and behavior by bears in woods. However, reactivation is impossible without leadership to explain what happened and what did not, and that rhetorical task might be beyond FDR himself. In every financial crisis, senior bankers have been available to explain and structure recovery, but this time the bankers’ conduct before, during, and after has been so without conscience that it may be another generation before financial-market Pooh-Bahs can earn back trust. If they tried, which they have not.
The politicians are prisoners of a homicidally angry people, and we’re going to stay in this pickle until we get over it.
The turn in these ISM surveys may be even more important than the often-revised payroll survey.
In a double surprise, the job market may at last have begun to revive, but the double-the-forecast, 243,000-job surge in January has done little harm to mortgages. We are still near 4.00%; 10-year T-notes up from 1.82%, but holding nicely at 1.95%.
Ordinarily a payroll jump like this would have killed us, especially in combination with strong results in the two ISM surveys for January: manufacturing to 54.1 from 53.1 in December, and service-sector way up to 56.8 from 52.6 last month. Some of the calm reaction in markets is suspicion — few other data confirm a big economic turn. Europe is a continuing cause of deep anxiety, but quiet this week, nothing but the muffled clanking of picks and shovels in the bottom of its ever-deeper hole.
And housing hangs over everything in the US economy, all measures of prices in continuing decline through December. But, to his great credit, Mr. Obama devoted a speech this week to housing, including new proposals. “This housing crisis struck right at the heart of what it means to be middle class in America: our homes.” Right!
The proposals will be without effect, but that’s not Mr. Obama’s fault. That two years have passed without proposals or priority or even mention, that is his fault, but give him full praise for saying out loud: “Hey, there’s an elephant in this living room!” Why there are no effective proposals, and why it’s beyond even the President’s power to put them forward is a tale of human nature. We know perfectly well what to do, but several things in ourselves and our political process prevent action.
Federal housing finance agencies created in the Great Depression were by far the most effective aspect of the New Deal, perhaps more so than all the rest put together. Aside from restoration of credit, the miracle of government guarantee made mortgage lending easy as apple pie. Guarantee and uniform underwriting standards — sound ones! — made previously illiquid and expensive mortgages as easy to transfer as shares of stock, and cheap, long after the Depression was gone.
For good or ill, as early as the end of WW II our homes became the stores of our national household wealth. Got to put it someplace. Stock market guys would like it to be their market, but it has its own epic instability. Houses it was. The original stop-the-Depression charter of the mortgage agencies became ordinary everyday-everybody utilities. We let them bloat, 1985-2004, for the interest of their stockholders, an inherently unstable situation. Even before mortgage credit went bonkers, ca. 2002, and the push for home ownership ran beyond qualified candidates, the ease of mortgage finance had likely over-fed housing wealth.
Here in the aftermath of the Bubble it is convenient to have someone to blame for our pain. “Fannie and Freddie” have become curse words. Profanities. They were NOT responsible for the $2 trillion in toxic loans, but they are big, fat targets for the Right, hating all government, also oddly the agencies’ boosters on the Left. Hell hath no fury like a social engineer scorned.
The truly culpable parties — Wall Street bankers — have made a clean getaway. John Dillinger and Clyde Barrow would still be in business if they had gone to Princeton, gotten MBAs, and learned to lie properly.
The result is self-inflicted paralysis. The plain-sight truth: for housing to recover we must re-activate Fannie. In a time of falling collateral value, private lenders cannot lend, and we must rely on government guarantee. That’s as certain as the Pope’s religion and behavior by bears in woods. However, reactivation is impossible without leadership to explain what happened and what did not, and that rhetorical task might be beyond FDR himself. In every financial crisis, senior bankers have been available to explain and structure recovery, but this time the bankers’ conduct before, during, and after has been so without conscience that it may be another generation before financial-market Pooh-Bahs can earn back trust. If they tried, which they have not.
The politicians are prisoners of a homicidally angry people, and we’re going to stay in this pickle until we get over it.
The turn in these ISM surveys may be even more important than the often-revised payroll survey.
Friday, January 27, 2012
Capital Markets Update
By Louis S. Barnes Friday, January 27th, 2012
“‘Stranger and stranger’, said Alice,” and so it was this week at the Fed, in Europe, and Mr. Obama’s State of the Union.
Some brave souls thought the Fed would surprise by rolling out QE3, and begin to buy more MBS, driving mortgage rates down. Everyone expected a pair of meaningless inside-Fed jokes (more transparency, and an inflation target) and we got those. Nobody expected this: to extend its zero-percent rate from 2013 to the end of 2014.
Bonds have rallied, the 10-year T-note back down to 1.92% and mortgages close to 4.00%, markets still adjusting. Bernanke’s term expires a year before the end of the new zero-rate period! 2014 is so far off in the economic future that nobody can know its conditions, but you can bet — bet a lot — that the Fed would make a three-year commitment only if it is seriously worried. That anxiety has penetrated even the stock market, which has sold off for the first time in years after a new easing by the Fed. The Fed’s concern was justified by today’s weaker-than-looks Q4 GDP report.
Europe… the ECB will NOT allow a bank to fail. Those dominoes are off the table. The ECB may or may not play the ultimate card, buying or second-stage monetizing Club Med wallpaper, but banks will not be the trigger for ultimate euro collapse.
However, the underlying disaster is still rolling along. Christine LaGarde, French Minister of Finance until last summer, now Managing Director of the IMF, this week delivered a speech worthy of the White Queen. “Why, sometimes I’ve believed as many as six impossible things before breakfast.” In grand French style, her speech soooo important, soooo without consequence: demand European growth measures simultaneous with cutting spending and raising taxes; a larger financial firewall but no source for the money; and deeper integration among cultures farther apart every day. Banks not in play, European economies will determine the next stage there.
“The state of the union is getting stronger.” Uh-huh. Fifteen hours and fifteen minutes after the President spoke those words, the Fed announced an economy in such peril that its previously unprecedented aid would extend over the horizon.
Okay. All Presidents have the right to use lipstick. However, forty minutes and 58 paragraphs into his words, words, and words, the President first mentioned “homeowner.” Gave it three sentences to describe a refinance proposal that does not exist and will not. Three weeks after the Fed Chairman, a Fed White Paper, and four other Fed governors and regional presidents identified housing as the most serious risk to the economy, why it is, and what to do about it… three empty sentences in the SOU.
The 12th and 69th paragraphs (only) contained the word “deficit” in self-congratulation for last year’s painful mini-cut. Nowhere in the speech was a reference to a domestic spending cut or planned spending discipline of any kind.
We are entering the second year of an inert White House. Blame the Tea party, rightly, but a second year with no meaningful, Congressional pass-able economic proposal? At all? When in modern times has the White House been so dormant?
FDR was active, heaven knows. Some still argue about what he did, but not that he tried with mighty invention. Harry Truman let no grass grow in a deadly time and with a hostile Congress. Ike knew how to use staff better than anybody; it got him time for golf, but he got stuff done, and ornery Democrat Sam Rayburn ran Congress. JFK’s two years had questionable result, but action! Statues of LBJ would be common had he not become entangled in Vietnam, as any President might in 1965. Odd, brilliant Dick Nixon was plenty productive until the last six months, and never had a Republican Congress. Gerry Ford restored faith and fought inflation. Jimmy Carter never connected, and micromanaged his way to oblivion, but was anything but asleep. Anything Ron Reagan got done in eight years had to be negotiated with Tip O’Neil. Daddy Bush faced nothing but Democrats, and Bill Clinton had to make deals with the Mad Hatter. Newt.
These last 11 years… I find no parallel except the emptiness of Harding and Coolidge. Hell, even Herbert Hoover tried hard.
Fourth Quarter GDP arrived plus 2.8%, but consumer spending rose only 2.0% (after all that media jive through the holidays), and the savings rate fell below 4%, leaving little slack in household budgets. Inventory rebuilding aside, GDP rose only 0.8%, and that was boosted by an improbable 10.9% jump in residential construction, likely to be revised closer to Q3′s 1.3% gain.
“‘Stranger and stranger’, said Alice,” and so it was this week at the Fed, in Europe, and Mr. Obama’s State of the Union.
Some brave souls thought the Fed would surprise by rolling out QE3, and begin to buy more MBS, driving mortgage rates down. Everyone expected a pair of meaningless inside-Fed jokes (more transparency, and an inflation target) and we got those. Nobody expected this: to extend its zero-percent rate from 2013 to the end of 2014.
Bonds have rallied, the 10-year T-note back down to 1.92% and mortgages close to 4.00%, markets still adjusting. Bernanke’s term expires a year before the end of the new zero-rate period! 2014 is so far off in the economic future that nobody can know its conditions, but you can bet — bet a lot — that the Fed would make a three-year commitment only if it is seriously worried. That anxiety has penetrated even the stock market, which has sold off for the first time in years after a new easing by the Fed. The Fed’s concern was justified by today’s weaker-than-looks Q4 GDP report.
Europe… the ECB will NOT allow a bank to fail. Those dominoes are off the table. The ECB may or may not play the ultimate card, buying or second-stage monetizing Club Med wallpaper, but banks will not be the trigger for ultimate euro collapse.
However, the underlying disaster is still rolling along. Christine LaGarde, French Minister of Finance until last summer, now Managing Director of the IMF, this week delivered a speech worthy of the White Queen. “Why, sometimes I’ve believed as many as six impossible things before breakfast.” In grand French style, her speech soooo important, soooo without consequence: demand European growth measures simultaneous with cutting spending and raising taxes; a larger financial firewall but no source for the money; and deeper integration among cultures farther apart every day. Banks not in play, European economies will determine the next stage there.
“The state of the union is getting stronger.” Uh-huh. Fifteen hours and fifteen minutes after the President spoke those words, the Fed announced an economy in such peril that its previously unprecedented aid would extend over the horizon.
Okay. All Presidents have the right to use lipstick. However, forty minutes and 58 paragraphs into his words, words, and words, the President first mentioned “homeowner.” Gave it three sentences to describe a refinance proposal that does not exist and will not. Three weeks after the Fed Chairman, a Fed White Paper, and four other Fed governors and regional presidents identified housing as the most serious risk to the economy, why it is, and what to do about it… three empty sentences in the SOU.
The 12th and 69th paragraphs (only) contained the word “deficit” in self-congratulation for last year’s painful mini-cut. Nowhere in the speech was a reference to a domestic spending cut or planned spending discipline of any kind.
We are entering the second year of an inert White House. Blame the Tea party, rightly, but a second year with no meaningful, Congressional pass-able economic proposal? At all? When in modern times has the White House been so dormant?
FDR was active, heaven knows. Some still argue about what he did, but not that he tried with mighty invention. Harry Truman let no grass grow in a deadly time and with a hostile Congress. Ike knew how to use staff better than anybody; it got him time for golf, but he got stuff done, and ornery Democrat Sam Rayburn ran Congress. JFK’s two years had questionable result, but action! Statues of LBJ would be common had he not become entangled in Vietnam, as any President might in 1965. Odd, brilliant Dick Nixon was plenty productive until the last six months, and never had a Republican Congress. Gerry Ford restored faith and fought inflation. Jimmy Carter never connected, and micromanaged his way to oblivion, but was anything but asleep. Anything Ron Reagan got done in eight years had to be negotiated with Tip O’Neil. Daddy Bush faced nothing but Democrats, and Bill Clinton had to make deals with the Mad Hatter. Newt.
These last 11 years… I find no parallel except the emptiness of Harding and Coolidge. Hell, even Herbert Hoover tried hard.
Fourth Quarter GDP arrived plus 2.8%, but consumer spending rose only 2.0% (after all that media jive through the holidays), and the savings rate fell below 4%, leaving little slack in household budgets. Inventory rebuilding aside, GDP rose only 0.8%, and that was boosted by an improbable 10.9% jump in residential construction, likely to be revised closer to Q3′s 1.3% gain.
Friday, January 20, 2012
Capital Markets Update
By Louis S. Barnes Friday, January 20, 2012
More positive US data and relaxation of European frights have combined for higher interest rates and support for Wall Street's warm-fuzzy machine.
One week ago, downgraded credit in Europe and another failure in Greek debt negotiations had taken the 10-year T-note to 1.85% and big-equity refis a hair below 4.00%. Today, nothing is resolved in Europe, but nothing is falling, either, so 10s are back to 2.02% and even a 20%-down low-fee mortgage is near 4.25%. Adios, refis.
The mortgage spread to 10s -- 2.25% -- is very wide, now opened in part by the new-mortgage surcharge inflicted by Congress and the White House to pay for part of the payroll tax cut. Which the public doesn't know, because mainstream media can't be bothered to cover the madness, and the Fed every day trying to close the spread.
The most striking US data is the decline in weekly claims for unemployment insurance, which seem decisively to have dropped below 400,000 (352,000 last week) where we had been stuck for most of 2011. Fewer layoffs is not hiring, but it is good news. Regional Feds report up-ticks in manufacturing. Inflation is receding from its commodity push last year, overall zero change in December CPI.
Then a data-interpretation argument, this time housing. The consensus is very optimistic that housing is past its bottom and 2012 will mark beginnings of recovery for construction and resales. I wish… oh, how I wish. The optimists assert pent-up demand, household formation, lower listed inventory, and faith. Halleluiah, brothers and sisters.
Always-suspect NAR has reported a 5% gain in sales of existing homes in December. Also a balmy, La Nina split-jet December, northern-city NFL finales and playoffs in dry 30-degree sunshine. Economic data is adjusted for season, but not weather. NAR also reported that one-third of contracts failed, its members correctly blaming mortgage underwriting and appraisals.
There is some legitimacy to hopes for new construction because builders are agile in shifting location and price point, and some places really are short of housing (North Dakota). However, new delinquencies are not improving, there is no work-off of distressed inventory, and all major measures of prices resumed their declines early last fall. The household-formation argument is based on recent historical pattern, but a hard look contradicts: we have a 1930s-style decline in birth rate, and for good or ill a sharp drop in illegal immigration. Pent-up demand is offset by pent-up caution about prices.
The void in political leadership continues, and among economic thinkers of all stripes the widening, hysterical scatter of what-to-do-if-you-were-king.
Heaven help moderates: Democrats were thrilled this week by Mitt Romney's exposure as wealthy (who knew?) and paying completely legal taxes, if low in some parts. This guy tithes, 10% of his considerable income to his church. Lefty Democrats think that tithing is taking 10% of somebody else's income, and Righty Republicans are in a 16th century argument about what a church is, and whose is acceptable.
Economic policy has two centers of confusion: stimulus versus austerity, and the central banks. Ordinarily sensible people chant: short-term stimulus, then austerity. Pardon: when is then? Less sensible people demand spending on infrastructure. Maybe we could avoid Japan's bridges-to-nowhere, but even nifty new bridges to somewhere add what multiplier to economic growth? Governor Moonbeam's California bullet trains are the most questionable public investment since the projects at Pruitt-Igoe.
The central banks. I hear more and more center-thinkers drifting toward the Libertarian posse. A good guide for 10 years has been the www.hoisingtonmgt.com quarterly, but the newest issue demands "a five-year moratorium on all new Fed actions." A bright, studious investment manager and friend (better nameless) refers to Fed "meddling." As we enjoy better US data, and no new recession, please understand that the Fed and ECB are holding open our living space against crushing deflationary pressures. And until accidental healing, or somebody finds the support to do useful things, the issue is in doubt and central banks are playing for time.
More positive US data and relaxation of European frights have combined for higher interest rates and support for Wall Street's warm-fuzzy machine.
One week ago, downgraded credit in Europe and another failure in Greek debt negotiations had taken the 10-year T-note to 1.85% and big-equity refis a hair below 4.00%. Today, nothing is resolved in Europe, but nothing is falling, either, so 10s are back to 2.02% and even a 20%-down low-fee mortgage is near 4.25%. Adios, refis.
The mortgage spread to 10s -- 2.25% -- is very wide, now opened in part by the new-mortgage surcharge inflicted by Congress and the White House to pay for part of the payroll tax cut. Which the public doesn't know, because mainstream media can't be bothered to cover the madness, and the Fed every day trying to close the spread.
The most striking US data is the decline in weekly claims for unemployment insurance, which seem decisively to have dropped below 400,000 (352,000 last week) where we had been stuck for most of 2011. Fewer layoffs is not hiring, but it is good news. Regional Feds report up-ticks in manufacturing. Inflation is receding from its commodity push last year, overall zero change in December CPI.
Then a data-interpretation argument, this time housing. The consensus is very optimistic that housing is past its bottom and 2012 will mark beginnings of recovery for construction and resales. I wish… oh, how I wish. The optimists assert pent-up demand, household formation, lower listed inventory, and faith. Halleluiah, brothers and sisters.
Always-suspect NAR has reported a 5% gain in sales of existing homes in December. Also a balmy, La Nina split-jet December, northern-city NFL finales and playoffs in dry 30-degree sunshine. Economic data is adjusted for season, but not weather. NAR also reported that one-third of contracts failed, its members correctly blaming mortgage underwriting and appraisals.
There is some legitimacy to hopes for new construction because builders are agile in shifting location and price point, and some places really are short of housing (North Dakota). However, new delinquencies are not improving, there is no work-off of distressed inventory, and all major measures of prices resumed their declines early last fall. The household-formation argument is based on recent historical pattern, but a hard look contradicts: we have a 1930s-style decline in birth rate, and for good or ill a sharp drop in illegal immigration. Pent-up demand is offset by pent-up caution about prices.
The void in political leadership continues, and among economic thinkers of all stripes the widening, hysterical scatter of what-to-do-if-you-were-king.
Heaven help moderates: Democrats were thrilled this week by Mitt Romney's exposure as wealthy (who knew?) and paying completely legal taxes, if low in some parts. This guy tithes, 10% of his considerable income to his church. Lefty Democrats think that tithing is taking 10% of somebody else's income, and Righty Republicans are in a 16th century argument about what a church is, and whose is acceptable.
Economic policy has two centers of confusion: stimulus versus austerity, and the central banks. Ordinarily sensible people chant: short-term stimulus, then austerity. Pardon: when is then? Less sensible people demand spending on infrastructure. Maybe we could avoid Japan's bridges-to-nowhere, but even nifty new bridges to somewhere add what multiplier to economic growth? Governor Moonbeam's California bullet trains are the most questionable public investment since the projects at Pruitt-Igoe.
The central banks. I hear more and more center-thinkers drifting toward the Libertarian posse. A good guide for 10 years has been the www.hoisingtonmgt.com quarterly, but the newest issue demands "a five-year moratorium on all new Fed actions." A bright, studious investment manager and friend (better nameless) refers to Fed "meddling." As we enjoy better US data, and no new recession, please understand that the Fed and ECB are holding open our living space against crushing deflationary pressures. And until accidental healing, or somebody finds the support to do useful things, the issue is in doubt and central banks are playing for time.
Friday, January 13, 2012
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


